skip to content
~11 min

Recap

The lesson in nine lines. First, what CAP says:

  • Two copies and a broken link: each side must answer from its own copy, or refuse.
  • A partition leaves both sides running, and from inside it looks like any reply that does not come.
  • Consistent: every answer reflects every change confirmed before its request, as if there were one copy.
  • Available: every running server answers every request, and an error is not an answer.
  • The theorem: where the network may cut two sides apart, no store keeps both.
  • P is not a choice. The choice is C or A, and only during a partition.

Then what it costs, and what it leaves out:

  • C costs errors now. A costs stale answers now and conflicts later.
  • CAP covers two exact promises and one fault, while the fault lasts, and nothing else.
  • Many real stores are neither CP nor AP.